Six-Star Movies

lime_1

When you write criticism, films and music primarily, you are constrained into rating a piece based on a set scale. This normally takes the form of a 4-star or 5-star pictorial option or a marks out-of-ten barometer to give your readership a quick and easy way to understand your sentiment towards what is being reviewed and gauge exactly which spectrum of the scale you fall in. Are you indifferent? Do you love the piece? Do you truly hate the piece? Is is somewhere lurking between all said options.

Occasionally, you come across something to review which is so utterly execrable, you award it no stars. This is a very satisfying and simple way to get across how awful something is. You can even slip into minus figures should it be, say, a Kevin Federline album or a Friedberg & Seltzer movie (or vice versa!). But, at the other end of the scale, there is little to satisfy should you find something which is so completely perfect that simply providing it with five-stars doesn’t seem enough. You will have already awarded five-stars to other pieces in the past and your thoughts will stray to how you could have done such a thing and placed it on even keel with the mastery you’ve experienced. Sometimes, you need to award an extra star, an extra mark, just to communicate the gravity of the situation.

Today I spent a magnificent 106 minutes rewatching Carol Reed’s masterpiece, The Third Man. It occurred to me once finishing that this really could not be fully encapsulated with a mere five-star review, which I’m sure it has received on a number of occasions in the past. The Third Man falls into a select group of films which can only really be categorised by six-stars, one extra, seemingly meaningless but symbolically imporatant further mark which will exhibit to readers everywhere that this is a film of such perfection, such untouchable brilliance, that it must be placed on a pedestal with only a select circle deserving of such praise. 

I would immediately throw out names like Vertigo, Seven Samurai, Ran (most Kurosawa masterworks), Taxi Driver, The Godfather Parts 1 & 2, A Bout de Souffle. Just a few off the top of the head which deserve to be categorised as six-star works, too perfect that they must be exalted outside of traditional ratings systems into a rarified position looking over the rest.

So, the question is, what films would you consider six-star works?

Advertisements

3 responses

  1. Hey guys. Great site. May I champion some more recent films for six-star status? Children of Men, Elephant, Irma Vep and A Brighter Summer Day.

  2. As much as I love Primer it’s still a 5-star film for me. It’s flawed in it’s execution but you can’t really fault Shane Carruth for that due to the minuscule budget he was working on.
    It’s still my favourite film of all time but I guess there are a few that I’d definitely give 6 stars to…

    2001
    Blade Runner
    Toy Story
    Stalker

  3. The old version of me would have said The Running Man. The newer and marginally improved version of me would list the following:

    Spirited Away
    Singin In The Rain
    The Thing

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: